GENOCIDE ? in GAZA: The blood libel of today

Charles Justin AM
GENOCIDE ? in GAZA
This lecture took place at the NGV on the 10 October, which from a timing perspective was after Bondi and at the closing stages of the Royal Commission on Antisemitism. It was delivered by Terry Smith, an esteemed Australian art historian, an Emeritus Professor at universities in Australia, US and Europe. The lecture was titled ‘ World Picturing by Contemporary Artists: Perceiving the Polycrisis’ The lecture attempted to consider how contemporary artists will respond to the simultaneous crises (environmental, economic, political) engulfing the world today and how their human vision will compare to the machine made vision in the digital sphere. The lecture was illustrated by examples of selected works by contemporary artists.
The key example, presented by Terry Smith representing the political crisis engulfing the world was the genocide in Gaza. No mention of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, or Iran’s mass murder of its own citizens coupled with its stated mission for the elimination of Israel through its proxies in the Middle East, that includes Hamas and Hezbollah. What’s happening in Gaza is tragic, and how Israel responded to the 7 October massacre is open to debate, but in the end what happened in Gaza is not genocide.
What are the facts relating to Israel committing genocide in Gaza? The definition of genocide in the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, requires proven intent by a perpetrator to destroy a people. There is no evidence that Israel has any policy or legislation for the destruction of the Palestinian people. Furthermore if you look at the numbers and not the optics, the accusation of genocide is totally unsupportable. According to the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS) the estimated population in Gaza in 1967 was 350,000, in 2023 was 2,100,000 and in 2025 was 2,300,000. In the first two years of the Gaza war, according to the Palestinians themselves, the Palestinian population grew by 200,000. A similar picture applies to the West Bank, in 1967 it was 600,000 and in 2025 it was 3,300,000. The annual population growth in the Palestinian territories is nearly double to that in Australia. In this context, Israel’s engagement with the Palestinians, cannot from any perspective be classified as genocide. Genocide is used exclusively for Israel. It is part of a global campaign to delegitimize and demonize Israel, particularly by reversing the character of the Holocaust and applying it to the Jews. It’s a form of blood libel. What is ironic that some of the worst perpetrators of this slander are the media, academia and the arts, who you would have thought would not only have the intellectual capacity to research and acknowledge the facts, but also have the professional and moral obligation to present information to the public or students that is objective, balanced and based on evidence.
What was insidious about the lecture, was that Terry Smith did not refer to Jews, Palestinians or Israel. The genocide in Gaza has become a meme, all you have to do to implicate Israel and the Jews is just mention the meme. This is how language is being weaponised, misrepresenting the facts by words being corrupted to mean what they are not. This also applies to terms such as Zionism, ethnic cleansing, colonialism, sovereignty, the list goes on. Gaza Genocide in Wikipedia runs to 120 pages, has 655 references from a list of works that runs to 22 pages. Contradicting Wikipedia, regarded as the paragon of independence and neutrality, in a single paragraph, seems Kafkaesque.
One of the artworks that Terry Smith highlighted to demonstrate how artists are responding to the Polycrisis, was Kith and Kin by Australian Indigenous artist Archie Moore. Installed at the Australian Pavilion at the Venice Biennale 2024. It went on to win the Golden Lion for the best National Participation, the first Australian artist to do so. The work consists of a monumental hand drawn family tree in white chalk across a 60 metre long 5 metre high black wall, that maps 65,000 years and over 2400 generations connecting his Kamilaroi, Bigambul, British and Scottish heritage. In the centre of the room sits a black pool of water above which is a table holding stacked, redacted official documents and coronial inquest reports into First Nations deaths in custody. I saw this work earlier this year at Queensland Art Gallery and it is a powerful, masterful work, deserving of its award. When I looked at this genealogical map drawn by Moore, it reminded me of the two family trees I was given by two genealogically driven distant cousins, one for each of my Holocaust survivor parents. Both family trees went back about 200 years, not quite 65,000 years, but each had a similar pattern, most of the tree branches ended in 1942.
Terry Smith presented Kith and Kin in the context of the genocide (his statement) of the Australian Aborigines. Although successive Australian Governments have pushed back on this designation, the facts are compelling. Prior to British arrival the Aboriginal population of Australia was estimated to be 2.22 million and in the next 70-150 years 90% had died from introduced diseases such as smallpox, frontier conflicts and displacement, where whole communities were destroyed and relocated. The stolen generation, the belated recognition of Aboriginals as citizens of Australia in 1969 as well as the belated recognition in 1996, of their occupation and rights to the land of Australia, added to its post-colonial shameful history.
What is implied in the application of genocide in this example, without being specifically stated, is that Jews are fulfilling the same role in Israel and Gaza as the British did in Australia. In fact the opposite is the case, Jews shouldn’t be identified with the colonisers but with Australia’s indigenous First Peoples. In Biblical times Jews had sovereignty over the land currently occupied by Israel, Westbank and Gaza, and constituted the vast proportion of the population. This is the land between the river and the sea. The word Jew comes from Judah, the biblical name of the country. It was only after the Jewish- Roman wars together and the resultant expulsion, followed by the 7th century Muslim conquests, did Jews become a minority in that land. Nonetheless they continued to live and have a presence in that land. Their sovereignty was never ceded. This is indisputable historic fact, so how can Jews be portrayed as white European colonisers of the indigenous Arab population? Again, another example of the misrepresentation and weaponizing of language. Jews returned to their historic homeland, not taking over someone else’s land as colonialists.
Australia and Israel have similar challenges, two distinct groups of peoples in each country, with different histories, both of whom have legitimate rights to live in that land. In both countries, these mutual rights have not been resolved. However the first fundamental step is that each side needs to recognize each other’s right to live in the land. In Australia the first Nation People have recognized that the Australia of today is a reality and are fighting for an equitable stake in the country, not to expel non-Aboriginals. In the Arab world there is a denial of Israel’s right to exist and for extremists like Iran and Hamas a stated objective to eliminate Israel. Why is this position not recognized as genocide? Why can’t some academics see this and why do they see and promote the opposite?
Where did this type of thinking come from. One explanation is in the fervent reaction to the horrors to WWII, led by the young and students, particularly In universities protesting against wars, such as in Vietnam, as well as against the use of atomic weapons as dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. They railed against colonialism, still entrenched in the third world, pushing for their independence. Movements such as women’s liberation, civil rights, gay rights, anti-apartheid, aboriginal recognition. Even protests on the restrictions in daily life on what we read, how we dress, how we fashion our hair, how we have sex, what we watch in the cinema and the music we listen to. The fight was for equality and freedom of expression. Unfortunately some of the theory behind these initiatives became radicalised, particularly in the humanities departments, through the perception of the dynamics of power- expressed in the binaries of the oppressed and oppressor, strong and weak, rich and poor, privileged and unprivileged and exploiters and exploited. Today many academics and students are guilty of this binary thinking and activism, that often over-ride the relevant facts and evidence to the contrary, resulting in the harassment, vilification, cancellation, isolation and attacks on Jewish staff and students. All this happening under the guise of freedom of expression.
Yuval Noah Harari, the Israeli historian, famous for his book, Sapiens: A Brief History of Mankind that caused a sensation around the world. In his recent book Nexus: A Brief History of Information Networks from the Stone Age to AI, Harari made two points that I found compelling. The first that Truth is subjective and is mediated by the perceptions and experiences of the individual. In contrast Fact is objective, as it is based on measurable evidence. Harari’s second point, that civilised human societies have two core components that make them work- freedom and order. However the balance between freedom and order is delicate, as the excessive weighting on one will be at the expense of the other. Today in Western liberal democracies, freedom of expression is highly regarded and protected. When that freedom of expression is weaponised due to some prejudice or ideology, it results in misinformation that ignores, twists or denies the facts, which is presented as truth. This we now experience online, in protests, in the media, in academia, in the arts and even on personal levels between colleagues, friends and even within families. The burning of synagogues and the massacre in Bondi didn’t occur in a vacuum, these occurred in a climate where fact is perverted and the voice to counter that perversion is drowned out. Jews need to be conscious that winning the military battles can’t be at the expense of losing the information war.
Charles Justin AM is an architect and art collector. A former President of the Jewish Museum of Australia and former Chair of the Melbourne Art Foundation, he cofounded with wife Leah the Justin Art House Museum- JAHM.




Comments