We don't need to agree before we begin to build bridges
By Esther Takac

Formidable obstacles stand in the way of Gadi Eisenkot forming Israel's next government. While significant political differences divide the parties that could form a change government, Jewish–Arab political partnership faces particularly deep mistrust and longstanding political taboos.
These divisions are rooted in decades of conflict, competing national narratives and profound pain, intensified by the trauma of October 7 and the devastating war that followed.
As a psychologist who works with trauma, I know that fear can narrow our capacity to understand the perspectives and experiences of others. When people feel profoundly threatened, they understandably prioritise safety and security. Fear also heightens mistrust, reinforces divisions and can make it harder to recognise the suffering and legitimate concerns of those we see as adversaries. These are human responses that affect communities on all sides of the conflict.
Professor Youssef Masharawi, an Arab Israeli academic at Tel Aviv University, recently posed a question many are grappling with: how can Arab citizens be welcomed as voters whose support is needed to bring about political change, while their elected representatives are considered unacceptable partners in government?
There are genuine and profound disagreements between the parties over national identity, security, the war and the future of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. These cannot simply be wished away. Recognising the equal political legitimacy of Arab citizens does not mean endorsing any particular coalition arrangement.
Opposition to particular Arab parties may reflect genuine disagreements over their policies and political positions. But those disagreements should not become a justification for treating Arab political representatives as inherently illegitimate partners.
This raises a larger question: must agreement come before cooperation? Or can cooperation itself become a way of building trust?
Steven Klein, who teaches conflict resolution and mediation at Tel Aviv University, suggests a practical way through the impasse. Rather than demanding agreement on fundamental ideological questions before cooperation can begin, Jewish and Arab parties could start by working together on shared priorities, such as establishing a state commission of inquiry into October 7, addressing crime and inequality in Arab communities, or strengthening democratic institutions.
Practical cooperation cannot substitute for confronting fundamental disagreements. The history of the Israeli–Palestinian peace process offers a caution against postponing the most difficult questions indefinitely. But neither should the absence of agreement on everything prevent progress where common ground exists. Working together on achievable goals may help build the relationships and trust needed to confront deeper disagreements.
The four bereaved Israelis and Palestinians at the heart of my documentary The Narrow Bridge offer a powerful illustration of this possibility.
Their lives have been shattered by the conflict. They have not abandoned their identities, their grief or their deeply held convictions. Nor have they necessarily come to agree about history or politics.
What has moved me most in following their journeys is not simply their willingness to recognise the suffering of the other, but their determination to turn that recognition into action. They have chosen to work together, speaking publicly, challenging entrenched narratives and advocating for reconciliation, despite the enormous emotional and political obstacles involved.
On Sunday, November 15, The Narrow Bridge screened at the Victorian Interfaith Festival in Melbourne, followed by a workshop exploring how storytelling and constructive conversations can help build understanding across religious, cultural and political divides.
Several people approached me afterwards, deeply moved by the film. One audience member captured something of its impact: “If people who have lost so much can somehow navigate through that storm to hope and reconciliation, then they are really calling out to us to do the same.”
But what does that mean in practice? How do we begin to engage constructively with people whose experiences, identities and beliefs are profoundly different from our own?
The Bridge Builders Social Cohesion Program, which grew out of the film, encourages us to cultivate four qualities essential to constructive conversations. We call them the Four Cs: courage to listen deeply and confront our own biases; compassion to recognise another's pain and act with kindness; curiosity to seek understanding rather than simply defend our positions; and creativity to find new ways of connecting and resolving differences.
Of course, a community workshop in Melbourne is not the same as negotiating to form a government in Israel, and building connections between individuals is not the same as transforming political relationships. Empathy and goodwill alone cannot resolve competing national aspirations, security concerns or structural inequalities. Political change requires difficult decisions, institutional commitments and a willingness to act on shared principles.
The call for cooperation is also being heard beyond Israel. The London Initiative, a network of Israeli and diaspora Jewish leaders, has called for a broad change coalition that includes willing Arab parties. A coalition that reflects the values of Israel's Declaration of Independence, including equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants, irrespective of religion, race or sex.
The question facing Israel is therefore larger than who will become its next prime minister. It is also about the kind of society Israelis want to build, and whether Jewish and Arab citizens can become genuine partners in shaping its future.
Perhaps we don't need to wait for trust before we begin building bridges. Sometimes it is through working together that trust begins to grow.
________________________________________
Esther Takac is a filmmaker, author and psychologist, director and producer of The Narrow Bridge and founder of the Bridge Builders Social Cohesion Program, which uses film and constructive conversations to foster understanding across religious, cultural and political divides.







Comments